Reduction of fuel consumption and gas emissions with Navigasa in Spain

The shipping company Naviera de Galicia S.A. operates three cargo vessels: the M/V Mandeo and the sisterships M/V Finita R and M/V Manuela E, all powered on intermediate fuel oil 180.

After having used a classic chemical additive during four years, the company decided to evaluate the XBEE Enzyme Fuel Technology on board the cargo ship M/V Finita R. The vessel is equipped with a Wärtsilä W6L32 main engine of 2,760 kW.

Navigasa fuel system cleaner

In order to ensure a precise and reliable monitoring of the evaluation, the following program has been carried out by the accredited laboratory Dekra:

  • On September 20, 2011 gas emissions of the ship’s main engine have been measured before the first fuel treatment with XBEE.
  • On February 28, 2013 the engine emissions have been measured again after 1,680 running hours on XBEE IFO 180.
  • In November 2013, the ship has been overhauled after a total of 21,268 running hours of the main engine.

Finally, on November 18, 2015 the laboratory Coterena embarked onboard the M/V Finita R to measure both gas emissions of the main engine for the third time after 27,992 running hours, and the specific fuel consumption.

This data has then been compared to Wärtsilä’s own protocol data.

Report by Dekra
Without XBEE
With XBEE
Difference
Temperature (°C)
296
254
-14.22%
Flue gas speed (m³/h)
15,020
15,498
+3.18%
O2 (%)
13.0
14.7
+13.32%
CO2 (%)
6.5
5.4
-16.50%
CO (mg/m³)
77.0
65.9
-14.41%
NOx (mg/m³)
1,866.0
788.9
-57.72%
SO2 (mg/m³)
1,984.0
680.3
-65.71%
COT (mg/m³)
26.1
33.7
-29.22%
Report by Coterena
Wärtsilä data
XBEE IFO 180
Difference
Power (kW)
1,676.7
1,689.6
Speed (RPM)
750.0
754.7
Specific fuel consumption (g/kWh)
199.90
190.5
-4.67%

Gas emissions measurements and specific fuel consumption data both show a significant improvement of the fuel combustion. The lack of correlation between -16.5% reduction of CO2 emissions and -4.67% reduction of fuel consumption is explained by the fact that consumption is based on Wärtsilä’s protocol data supplied by the laboratory.

Moreover, the pictures here above confirm the same, as we can see a clear improvement in cleanliness of pistons, valves, and rings.